Skip to content

Adjustable gastric banding has declined in the U.S. market due to lower efficacy and higher complications

Adjustable gastric banding, often referred to as gastric banding or lap band surgery, is a type of bariatric surgery used to treat obesity. It involves placing a band around the upper part of the stomach to create a small pouch, which limits the amount of food that can be consumed at one time and promotes a feeling of fullness with smaller meals.

Adjustable gastric banding, also known as lap band surgery, is a procedure that involves placing an adjustable band around the upper part of the stomach to help with weight loss.

Step-by-step description of the process for Adjustable gastric banding

  1. Preoperative Preparation:
    • The patient undergoes a thorough medical evaluation, including lab tests and possibly psychological evaluation, to ensure they are a suitable candidate for the surgery.
    • The patient is typically placed under general anesthesia, meaning they will be unconscious during the procedure.
  2. Incision and Access:
    • The surgery is usually performed laparoscopically, which involves making several small incisions in the abdomen.
    • A laparoscope (a thin tube with a tiny camera) and surgical instruments are inserted through these incisions.
  3. Placement of the Gastric Band:
    • The surgeon carefully places an inflatable silicone band around the upper part of the stomach, creating a small pouch above the band.
    • The band is connected via a narrow tube to an access port, which is positioned under the skin in the abdominal wall.
  4. Adjustment of the Band:
    • Initially, the band may be left partially or completely deflated.
    • Over time, the band can be adjusted by injecting or removing saline solution through the access port to tighten or loosen the band as needed. This adjustment is done in the surgeon’s office.
  5. Closure and Recovery:
    • The incisions are closed with stitches or surgical staples.
    • The patient is monitored in a recovery area until they are stable enough to be moved to a hospital room or discharged home.
  6. Postoperative Care:
    • Patients typically follow a liquid diet for a few weeks after surgery, gradually transitioning to soft foods and then regular foods.
    • Regular follow-up appointments are scheduled to monitor the patient’s progress, adjust the band, and address any concerns.
  7. Long-Term Management:
    • Patients are encouraged to maintain a healthy diet and exercise regimen to support their weight loss goals.
    • The band may need to be adjusted periodically to ensure optimal results.

Adjustable gastric banding is a reversible procedure, and the band can be removed if necessary. However, it’s important for patients to understand that the surgery is not a quick fix and requires significant lifestyle changes to achieve and maintain weight loss.

Step-by-step description of the process for Adjustable gastric banding
Step-by-step description of the process for Adjustable gastric banding

The general guidelines for who may be a good candidate for this procedure and who may not:

Suitable Candidates:

  1. BMI of 40 or Higher:
    • Individuals with a body mass index (BMI) of 40 or higher, which is considered severely obese, are often considered for adjustable gastric banding.
  2. BMI Between 35 and 40 with Comorbidities:
    • People with a BMI between 35 and 40 who have obesity-related health conditions such as type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, or sleep apnea may also be candidates if they have not been successful with other weight loss methods.
  3. Commitment to Lifestyle Changes:
    • Candidates should be motivated and committed to making long-term changes in their diet and exercise habits to support their weight loss and overall health.
  4. Good General Health:
    • Individuals should be in relatively good health, with no major medical conditions that could complicate surgery or recovery.
  5. Realistic Expectations:
    • Candidates should have realistic expectations about the outcomes of the surgery and understand that it is a tool to assist with weight loss, not a cure-all.

Unsuitable Candidates:

  1. Pregnant Women:
    • Women who are pregnant or planning to become pregnant in the near future are not suitable for this surgery, as weight loss during pregnancy can be dangerous.
  2. Substance Abuse:
    • Individuals with a history of substance abuse may not be considered suitable candidates, as they may not be able to adhere to the necessary lifestyle changes and follow-up care.
  3. Severe Cardiovascular or Pulmonary Disease:
    • People with severe cardiovascular or pulmonary conditions that could be exacerbated by surgery or rapid weight loss may not be good candidates.
  4. Certain Gastrointestinal Disorders:
    • Those with certain gastrointestinal disorders, such as Crohn’s disease or severe gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), may not be suitable for adjustable gastric banding.
  5. Mental Health Conditions:
    • Individuals with untreated mental health conditions, such as severe depression or eating disorders, may not be considered suitable until their conditions are adequately managed.

Consult with a bariatric surgeon and a multidisciplinary team to determine if adjustable gastric banding is the right choice for an individual’s specific situation. The decision is based on a comprehensive evaluation of the patient’s medical history, lifestyle, and personal goals.

Potential complications of Adjustable gastric banding

Adjustable gastric banding, like any surgical procedure, carries potential complications.

Here are some of the possible complications associated with this type of bariatric surgery:

  1. Band Slippage or Erosion:
    • The band may slip out of place or erode into the stomach wall, which can cause symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, and difficulty swallowing. This may require additional surgery to correct.
  2. Infection:
    • Infections can occur at the site of the incisions or around the band or port. Antibiotics may be prescribed, and in severe cases, the band may need to be removed.
  3. Port Problems:
    • The access port may become dislodged, leak, or develop an infection. Adjustments or replacements may be necessary.
  4. Stomach Perforation:
    • A rare but serious complication, stomach perforation can occur during the placement of the band, requiring emergency surgery.
  5. Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GERD):
    • Some patients may experience an increase in acid reflux after the surgery, which may require medication or further intervention.
  6. Nutritional Deficiencies:
    • Due to the reduced intake of food, patients may develop deficiencies in vitamins and minerals such as iron, calcium, and vitamin B12. Regular monitoring and supplementation are typically required.
  7. Stenosis (Narrowing of the Stomach Outlet):
    • The opening between the stomach pouch and the rest of the stomach may become too narrow, causing difficulty in swallowing and requiring dilation or adjustment of the band.
  8. Slippage of the Stomach Pouch:
    • The stomach pouch can sometimes slide down below the band, causing symptoms similar to band slippage.
  9. Band Leakage:
    • The band itself may develop a leak, which can affect its function and may require replacement.
  10. Psychological Issues:
    • Some patients may experience psychological issues after surgery, including depression, anxiety, or body image concerns, which may require counseling or other forms of support.

Patients to discuss these potential complications with their surgeon and to follow all postoperative care instructions to minimize the risk of complications. Regular follow-up with a healthcare team experienced in bariatric surgery is crucial for monitoring and managing any issues that may arise.

Potential complications of Adjustable gastric banding
Potential complications of Adjustable gastric banding

The effectiveness of adjustable gastric banding for weight loss

The effectiveness of adjustable gastric banding for weight loss can be evaluated through several key indicators.

Some common ways to assess the outcomes of this bariatric surgery:

  1. Weight Loss:
    • The primary measure of effectiveness is the amount of weight lost. This is typically expressed as a percentage of excess body weight lost (%EWL) or a percentage of total body weight lost (%TWL). Patients are usually considered successful if they lose 50% or more of their excess body weight within the first two years after surgery.
  2. BMI Reduction:
    • The reduction in body mass index (BMI) is another important indicator. A significant decrease in BMI, particularly into the normal or overweight range, is indicative of successful weight loss.
  3. Resolution of Comorbidities:
    • Improvement or resolution of obesity-related health conditions such as type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, sleep apnea, and joint pain is an important measure of the surgery’s effectiveness.
  4. Quality of Life:
    • Assessments of quality of life, including physical function, emotional well-being, and social functioning, can be used to evaluate the impact of weight loss on the patient’s overall health and happiness.
  5. Adherence to Follow-Up Care:
    • Regular follow-up visits to adjust the band, monitor nutritional status, and address any complications are crucial for long-term success. Adherence to these recommendations is an indirect measure of the surgery’s effectiveness.
  6. Patient Satisfaction:
    • Surveys and interviews can be used to gauge patient satisfaction with the results of the surgery and their overall experience.
  7. Long-Term Weight Maintenance:
    • The ability to maintain weight loss over the long term is a critical factor in assessing the effectiveness of adjustable gastric banding. This may involve continued follow-up and support to help patients maintain healthy habits.

The effectiveness of adjustable gastric banding can vary widely among individuals, and some patients may not achieve the same level of weight loss as others. Additionally, the surgery is not a cure for obesity and requires ongoing commitment to lifestyle changes and follow-up care to achieve and maintain weight loss.

Advantages and disadvantages of adjustable gastric banding

Each type of surgery has its own advantages and disadvantages. Here are some of the pros and cons of adjustable gastric banding compared to other bariatric surgeries:

Advantages:

  1. Reversibility:
    • One of the main advantages of adjustable gastric banding is that it is reversible. The band can be removed if necessary, and the stomach generally returns to its original shape.
  2. Adjustability:
    • The band can be adjusted to accommodate changes in the patient’s weight loss needs or medical condition. This can be done non-surgically by injecting or removing saline through the access port.
  3. Lower Risk of Malabsorption:
    • Unlike some other bariatric surgeries, such as gastric bypass, adjustable gastric banding does not typically cause malabsorption of nutrients. This reduces the risk of nutritional deficiencies.
  4. Minimally Invasive:
    • The surgery is usually performed laparoscopically, which means smaller incisions and a shorter recovery time compared to more invasive procedures.
  5. Reduced Food Intake:
    • The band restricts the amount of food that can be consumed at one time, leading to a feeling of fullness with smaller meals.

Disadvantages:

  1. Slower Weight Loss:
    • Adjustable gastric banding typically results in slower weight loss compared to other bariatric surgeries, such as gastric bypass or sleeve gastrectomy.
  2. Potential for Band Slippage or Erosion:
    • The band may slip out of place or erode into the stomach, which can cause complications and may require additional surgery.
  3. Need for Regular Adjustments:
    • The band requires regular adjustments to maintain its effectiveness, which can be inconvenient and may cause discomfort.
  4. Less Effective for Severe Obesity:
    • Some studies suggest that adjustable gastric banding may be less effective for patients with severe obesity (BMI > 50) compared to other bariatric surgeries.
  5. Potential for Weight Regain:
    • If the band is not properly maintained or if lifestyle changes are not sustained, there is a risk of weight regain.
  6. Psychological Factors:
    • Some patients may find the psychological aspects of having a foreign object in their body difficult to adjust to, and there may be issues related to body image or self-esteem.

Each type of surgery has its own set of risks and benefits, and what works best for one person may not be the best option for another.

Advantages and disadvantages of adjustable gastric banding
Advantages and disadvantages of adjustable gastric banding

Development History of adjustable gastric banding

The history of adjustable gastric banding can be traced back to the 1980s when the concept of using a band to restrict stomach size was first introduced. Here is a brief overview of its development:

  1. Early Concepts (1980s): The idea of using a band to restrict the stomach was initially explored in the early 1980s. Various prototypes were developed, but they were not widely adopted due to complications and the lack of adjustability.
  2. Development of the Swedish Band (1985): In 1985, a Swedish surgeon named Lars-?ke Brostr?m developed the first commercially available gastric band, known as the Swedish Adjustable Gastric Band (SAGB). This band was made of silicone and could be adjusted via an injection port placed under the skin.
  3. Introduction of the Lap-Band (1993): In 1993, the Lap-Band system was introduced by a company called BioEnterics Corporation. This system was an improvement over the Swedish band and became more widely used due to its adjustability and lower risk of complications. The Lap-Band was approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2001.
  4. Technological Advancements and Global Adoption (1990s-2000s): Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, the technology behind gastric bands continued to improve. Different types of bands were developed, and the procedure became more refined. By the early 2000s, adjustable gastric banding had become one of the most common bariatric surgeries worldwide.
  5. Challenges and Decline (2010s): In the 2010s, concerns about the long-term effectiveness and complications associated with gastric banding led to a decline in its popularity. Some studies suggested that the procedure was not as effective as other bariatric surgeries, such as gastric bypass and sleeve gastrectomy, in achieving sustained weight loss and resolving obesity-related health issues.
  6. Current Status: While adjustable gastric banding is still an option for some patients, it is less commonly performed today compared to other bariatric procedures. The focus has shifted towards procedures that offer more significant and sustained weight loss, such as sleeve gastrectomy and gastric bypass.

In summary, adjustable gastric banding has evolved from early concepts in the 1980s to a widely adopted surgical procedure in the 1990s and 2000s, before facing challenges and a decline in popularity in the 2010s. Despite its reduced use, it remains a treatment option for obesity, particularly for patients who may not be suitable candidates for more invasive procedures.

Market situation

Adjustable gastric banding has seen a significant shift in its market status within the United States over the past decade. Here’s an analysis of its current market situation:

  1. Decline in Popularity: Adjustable gastric banding has experienced a notable decline in popularity in the U.S. This is largely due to the perception that it is less effective than other bariatric surgeries, such as gastric bypass and sleeve gastrectomy, in achieving long-term weight loss and resolving obesity-related health conditions. Additionally, the procedure has been associated with a higher rate of complications and the need for additional surgeries to revise or remove the band.
  2. Reduced Insurance Coverage: Many insurance companies have reduced or eliminated coverage for adjustable gastric banding procedures. This is partly because of the procedure’s lower success rate compared to other bariatric surgeries and the higher likelihood of requiring subsequent surgeries. As a result, fewer patients opt for this procedure due to the financial burden.
  3. Limited Availability: With the decline in demand and insurance coverage, fewer surgeons are offering adjustable gastric banding as a primary bariatric surgery option. This has led to a reduction in the number of facilities performing the procedure, further limiting its availability to patients.
  4. Alternative Procedures: The market for bariatric surgery in the U.S. has seen a shift towards more invasive procedures that offer greater weight loss outcomes, such as gastric bypass and sleeve gastrectomy. These procedures have been shown to be more effective in achieving significant and sustained weight loss, which is a primary goal for many patients seeking bariatric surgery.
  5. Patient Selection: Adjustable gastric banding is still considered an option for certain patients, particularly those who may not be suitable candidates for more invasive procedures due to medical reasons. However, the selection process for this procedure is more stringent, focusing on patients who are less likely to require extensive weight loss or who have specific health conditions that make other procedures riskier.
  6. Innovation and Research: Despite the decline, there is ongoing research and innovation aimed at improving the outcomes of adjustable gastric banding. This includes developing new types of bands, refining surgical techniques, and exploring ways to enhance patient compliance with post-operative care.

In conclusion, adjustable gastric banding has a diminished market presence in the U.S. due to its perceived lower efficacy, higher complication rates, and reduced insurance coverage. The procedure is now primarily offered to a select group of patients who are not suitable candidates for other bariatric surgeries, and its availability has decreased as a result. The future of adjustable gastric banding may depend on further advancements in technology and surgical techniques that can improve its effectiveness and safety.

  1. Cleveland Clinic – Located in Cleveland, Ohio, the Cleveland Clinic is a renowned medical institution that offers a range of bariatric surgery options, including adjustable gastric banding. It is known for its comprehensive approach to patient care, with a multidisciplinary team that includes surgeons, dietitians, psychologists, and other specialists to support patients throughout their weight loss journey.
  2. Johns Hopkins Hospital – Situated in Baltimore, Maryland, Johns Hopkins Hospital is a leading healthcare provider that offers adjustable gastric banding among its bariatric surgery options. The hospital is recognized for its excellence in research and innovation, and its bariatric surgery program is accredited by the American College of Surgeons Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery Accreditation and Quality Improvement Program (MBSAQIP).
  3. Mayo Clinic – With locations in Rochester, Minnesota, Phoenix/Scottsdale, Arizona, and Jacksonville, Florida, the Mayo Clinic is a prestigious medical center that provides a wide range of medical services, including adjustable gastric banding. The bariatric surgery program at Mayo Clinic is known for its patient-centered care and commitment to evidence-based practices.
  4. University of Michigan Health System – Located in Ann Arbor, Michigan, the University of Michigan Health System offers adjustable gastric banding as part of its comprehensive bariatric surgery services. The program is accredited by the MBSAQIP and is known for its focus on research and education, as well as its commitment to providing high-quality care to patients with obesity.

These hospitals are among the many healthcare institutions in the United States that offer adjustable gastric banding, each with its own expertise and approach to patient care. It’s important for patients to research and consider all options when choosing a healthcare provider for bariatric surgery.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *